The Most Beloved "Bad" Athletes

By (Featured Columnist) on January 4, 2013

19,895 reads

20Icon_comment

Previous
1 of 22
Next
Hi-res-158766739_crop_650x440
Harry How/Getty Images

It's easy to see why guys like LeBron James, Derek Jeter and Peyton Manning are so beloved—they're winners who happen to have charisma to match their talents.

But what about those guys that aren't as successful, yet just as lovable?

Though we know they'll never lead our favorite team to a title or lead the league in any major categories, here are the bad athletes we just can't help but love.

Spud Webb

Hi-res-1125821_display_image
Tim DeFrisco/Getty Images

We feel bad putting a fellow shorty on here, but besides winning the Dunk Contest a long, long time ago, what has Webb done?

For someone who averaged about 10 ppg in his career, he sure does get a hell of a lot of love from people.

He may have led little guys to think they could dunk, but he wasn't a great player besides that.

Philip Rivers

Hi-res-158819862_display_image
Donald Miralle/Getty Images

Yes, we said it.

For all the love that Rivers gets from fans and media, what has he done besides a couple Pro Bowls and leading the Chargers to a couple playoff games?

Not to be confused with being overrated, Rivers is one of the most inconsistent players in the league. For the face of the franchise and former No. 4 pick in a draft boasting Super Bowl-winning QBs Eli Manning and Ben Roethlisberger, he hasn't pulled his weight for all the praise he gets.

Will Middlebrooks

Hi-res-150007131_display_image
Jim Rogash/Getty Images

At only 23 years old with one season in the Majors under his belt, the jury's still out on Middlebrooks as to what he'll be in his career.

Based off the popularity he enjoyed during the 2012 season though, it's clear fans' expectations are high for him.

He did hit .288 with 15 bombs while driving in 54, so he could have some potential. For the Red Sox front office, they certainly hope they were right, as they traded away Kevin Youkilis last year to make Middlebrooks the full-timer at the hot corner.

Anna Kournikova

Hi-res-110665524_display_image
Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images

For our money, there wasn't a better looking chick in a tennis skirt than Kournikova.

Aside from her being a dime-piece though, she didn't accomplish much on the court, failing to ever live up to the hype that came with her.

However, thanks to her side gigs like modeling and dating high-profile celebs, she's got a following like it's no one's business.

Shea Weber

Hi-res-144159858_display_image
Christian Petersen/Getty Images

Shea Weber is regarded as a top blue-liner in the NHL, so when the Preds re-upped the defenseman to a $110 million contract over the next 14 years, it was warranted in far of losing both he and Ryan Suter in the same offseason.

To get that type of cash though, we think of franchise-changing guys like Evgeni Malkin and Henrik Sedin, not a guy that's best known for just shutting-down an opposition's best offensive threat.

Jonathan Papelbon

Hi-res-152773830_display_image
Drew Hallowell/Getty Images

He's not a bad pitcher, he's just a little overrated for the weight his name carries.

When Pap was a free agent following the 2011 season, we're sure he had enough star power to convince you he'd be too expensive for a small-market team like your city's to ever sign him.

But upon further review, if you look at his stats, it wasn't as if he was the second coming of Lee Smith here, and was probably more of a beneficiary of the Red Sox aura than anything else.

He signed with the Phils in 2012, earning a $50 million contract over four years, before going out and giving up the most homers of his career (8), and going 5-6, and 38 for 42 in save situations with a 2.44 ERA.

Not terrible, but not dominant either.

Doug Flutie

Hi-res-51434043_display_image
Ronald Martinez/Getty Images

There were so many fans who fell in love with this guy during his career thanks to his desire and past, but if you take a look at his stats, you'll see why it was more than just his short stature that prohibited him from starting more in the NFL.

A 76.3 passer rating and low-50s completion percentage isn't a very good way to become the face of a franchise, but thanks to him turning his own mug into a brand, many fell in love with him.

Shawn Bradley

Hi-res-2960877_display_image
Brian Bahr/Getty Images

Thanks to his 7'6" frame, Bradley enjoyed an astonishing 12-year career.

He may have never achieved stardom—unless you count all the posters he ended up on—but because he was always the tallest guy in the building, and became a punchline for most fans, he often gets brought up way too much as someone who actually did more than his stats would suggest.

Charlie Batch

Hi-res-157470323_display_image
Rob Carr/Getty Images

The 12-year vet is one of the most respected and well-liked players in the league, but just because he's a nice guy, doesn't mean he's had great success in his career.

Your favorite team could do worse than having him as their backup, but he should never be a viable option for more than a couple games because he's not very good.

Danica Patrick

Hi-res-156660678_display_image
Chris Trotman/Getty Images

Starring in commercials with supermodels certainly has its perks, doesn't it?

At least it does for Patrick who, though her career stats aren't at all that impressive, annually falls under the most beloved athletes.

We love to look at her, but it's usually not in a fire-resistant suit while wearing a helmet.

Matt Cassel

Hi-res-156659510_display_image
Jamie Squire/Getty Images

We hate picking on a guy who famously got booed by his home fans while on the ground with an injury, but the fact is, Cassel's not a very good NFL quarterback—especially when you realize what he's getting paid.

He's enjoyed a couple good seasons in the league, but not nearly enough to warrant his contract or incumbent starting status...until next year, that is, once the Chiefs most likely grab a quarterback in the draft.

Lolo Jones

Hi-res-149952084_display_image
Jamie Squire/Getty Images

Jones is one of the most attractive and recognizable athletes out there—assuming you don't get her confused with actress Rashida Jones.

But for no reason should she be popular for her performances on the track because, well, she hasn't done anything memorable yet.

Need to know more? Here's a great story of how she got so popular without career success.

Reggie Bush

Hi-res-158819092_display_image
Jim Rogash/Getty Images

Since arriving in Miami, Reggie's seen his game step up big time, breaking the 1,000-yard barrier in 2011, and narrowly missing it again this year (986 yards).

But getting a fat stack isn't what it used to be for measuring NFL backs.

He's failed to live up to everyone's expectations, yet still has people fall in love with the things he used to do while at USC.

Rickie Fowler

Hi-res-157358142_display_image
Stephen Dunn/Getty Images

We love Fowler for his total broness and carefree attitude with his other golfing buddies, but as much as we think it'd be cool to sit down and drink some brews with him, he hasn't quite attained great success on tour yet.

We're hoping he has himself a solid 2013 season to prove us wrong, but until then, he'll just be that dope-looking dude.

Lamar Odom

Hi-res-158629428_display_image
Stephen Dunn/Getty Images

It's not that Odom hasn't had a solid career, but for as much talk as he gets from sports media, you'd think he was a future Hall of Famer.

His popularity obviously stems from his reality show with his Kardashian wife Khloe, but he still doesn't deserve this much love from all of us.

JaVale McGee

Hi-res-156514621_display_image
Doug Pensinger/Getty Images

If you've ever watched TNT's Shaqtin' a Fool, you know why JaVale is so high on our list.

Known for being aloof, uncoordinated and just clumsy, McGee epitomizes the average NBA player.

He's tall. 

And strong.

But he lacks the focus to be more than just a punchline for most people.

Leryn Franco

Hi-res-130639578_display_image
Scott Heavey/Getty Images

We're used to seeing Leryn No. 1 on lists such as hottest Olympic athletes, so why does she fall so high here too?

As much as it pains us to say it, forget her overall sexiness for a second and check her stats.

She's never won anything during major competitions, yet she still finds herself all over the news and in mags.

Being that big of a smokeshow will do that though.

Tim Tebow

Hi-res-158819723_display_image
Rick Stewart/Getty Images

It's not like Tebow hasn't proven he can be a starting quarterback in the league, after all, he did lead the Broncos to the playoffs and a wild-card win over the Steelers last year.

Unfortunately, his lack of development in throwing the football has limited his opportunities in the NFL.

We're not calling him a bad athlete, but in comparison to the potential he showed while at Florida, he hasn't met expectations. 

Daniel "Rudy" Ruettiger

Image via allswagga.com
Image via allswagga.com

We all know the story—or at least the Hollywood version of it.

Rudy was the little runt that could, fighting his way with a chip on his shoulder to live out his dream of running out of the tunnel and onto Notre Dame's field back in 1975.

As many tears that have fallen down your face from that final scene from the flick, his inspiring story is his one claim to fame.

Brian Scalabrine

Hi-res-109813752_display_image
Rob Carr/Getty Images

Has there ever been a more beloved player who accomplished so little during his career in NBA history?

Chants of "Scalabrine! Scalabrine! Scalabrine!" could be heard around any home arena he ever played for once the game's outcome was all but decided.

Hell there's even a video that sums up his entire career highlights.

Begin Slideshow
Keep Reading
Flag
Props (1)
This article is

What is the duplicate article?

Why is this article offensive?

Where is this article plagiarized from?

Why is this article poorly edited?

Flag This Article
Default-user-icon-comment
or to post a comment

20 Comments

There are no comments yet. Get the conversation started by leaving the first comment
Big
Loading comments...
just now posted just now
  • Loading...
  • Nobody has liked this comment yet
Cancel

This comment and all replies have been deleted This comment has been deleted Undo delete

Follow B/R on Facebook

See more articles »

Fans of

Icon_subscribe
Icon_youtube
Icon_google
Sports and Pop Culture

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address

Thanks for signing up.

We're Scouting Top Writers