Debate: Is AP or Peyton the Better Candidate for Comeback Player of the Year?

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Debate: Is AP or Peyton the Better Candidate for Comeback Player of the Year?
Joe Robbins/Getty Images

Adrian Peterson and Peyton Manning have both had incredible comeback years in 2012.


Agree with someone's comment? Vote for it to make the Debate Highlights section. Disagree with a comment? Reply and voice your opinion. Happy Debating!

Add Comment


OK, this is one of those situations where both guys have done an incredible job coming back from career threatening injuries. It is rare that a runnin...
Full Comment »
Peyton is almost 10 years older than AP. To come back from multiple surgeries and, not only throw for over 4,000 yards and 30 tds, but to lead a team...
Full Comment »
Peyton is not just coming back from a potentially career ending injury. He's coming back after taking an entire season off. To overcome that at his ...
Full Comment »
Gotta say AP. If he breaks the record after his surgery, it will be unbelievable. Peyton's accomplishments can't be diminished though.
Full Comment »
wow this guy has no clue what he is even talking about. Broncos made it to the playoffs last season with TIM TEBOW and won a playoff game. Vikings h...
Full Comment »
Lifelong Viking fan in me says it should go to AP. But for either of these guys to be snubbed of the award is blasphemy. This is one instance where I ...
Full Comment »

Countdown Clock

Out of Bounds


Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address

Thanks for signing up.