Newcastle vs. Manchester City: Score, Grades and Post-Match Reaction

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Newcastle vs. Manchester City: Score, Grades and Post-Match Reaction
Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images

Manchester City made it look easy at St. James' Park on Saturday, cruising past Newcastle United and adding three big points to their Premier League total with a hard-fought 3-1 win.

Roberto Mancini's men got a huge boost early when Sergio Aguero put them ahead 1-0 just 10 minutes into the match. Less than a half hour later, Javi Garcia would put City up 2-0 with a 39th-minute header. 

Newcastle forward Demba Ba made things interesting shortly after halftime, scoring in the 51st minute to cut City's lead in half. But after nearly a half-hour of scoreless action, City midfielder Yaya Toure put the match away with a 78th-minute goal. The Blues would go on to win, 3-1.

The victory moves City three points closer to Premier League-leading Manchester United in the table.

Richard Whittall explains via Twitter how quickly the opinions of many experts, including those of commentator Ian Darke, changed on Saturday:

Meanwhile, Michael Curry expressed the importance of Newcastle bringing the same energy into their next match:

Rob Summerfield had some intriguing criticism about City's players during the first half on Saturday:

Whether they were flopping or not, here we break down some of Saturday's key performers and hand out a grade to each.


Carlos Tevez, Manchester City: B

Stu Forster/Getty Images

Lethal Manchester City striker Carlos Tevez may have not scored a goal on Saturday, but his activity up front for Mancini's club was worth a solid B. Tevez played energized and had five shots to show for his effort. 

Danny Simpson, Newcastle United: C

Danny Simpson was arguably Newcastle's worst defender on Saturday, earning a 27th-minute yellow card and committing several fouls. Although he wasn't solely to blame for the three goals Newcastle conceded, he is worthy of being singled out for a less-than-solid performance vs. City.

This tweet from George Davis expresses the frustration a lot of Newcastle fans felt on Saturday:

Sergio Aguero, Manchester City: B

Sure, Sergio Aguero's early goal was huge for City's confidence and their result this weekend, but although it was spectacular, it came with little pressure attached. Plus, not long after Aguero picked up a yellow card, his side's first of the match.

Liverpool's Brad Smith described Aguero's goal on Twitter as something one would see in a video game:

Aguero shouldn't be punished for scoring first, but his mistake that earned him a yellow card in the first half takes his performance down a notch, earning him a B. 

Demba Ba, Newcastle United: A

Stu Forster/Getty Images

Demba Ba's second-half goal was the only reason Newcastle were even able to chase a point late in Saturday's match. Ba cut City's lead in half not long after halftime, providing the home squad with a shot to level the match late. 

Ba was the only Newcastle player to show up on the scoreboard on Saturday and also put up six shots, two of which fell on target. Therefore, he earns an A for his productive outing. 

Javi Garcia, Manchester City: A

Sergio Aguero may have ignited City's scoring, but midfielder Javi Garcia is credited with the game-winning goal. Garcia's first-half score proved to be the difference, thus earning him the highest grade possible.

Here's Garcia celebrating with his teammates following his sweet finish (via Manchester City's official Twitter account):

The reaction says it all and best sums up City's result on Saturday.

Follow Bleacher Report Featured Columnist Patrick Clarke on Twitter. 

Follow _Pat_Clarke on Twitter

Follow B/R on Facebook

Premier League

Subscribe Now

By signing up for our newsletter, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Thanks for signing up.