Carson Palmer vs Terrelle Pryor: Which QB Makes More Sense for Raiders' Offense?

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Carson Palmer vs Terrelle Pryor: Which QB Makes More Sense for Raiders' Offense?
Christian Petersen/Getty Images

The Oakland Raiders have nothing to lose in 2012.

Carson Palmer isn't the reason for the team's woes, but with a record of 1-4 it makes perfect sense to give Terrelle Pryor a shot to see what he's got before the 2013 NFL draft. 

General Manager Reggie McKenzie has this team in a full-on rebuilding mode. Before the season began, Raiders fans were optimistic about their team's chances, but the sad truth is that there wasn't enough talent on the roster to field a winning team. 

Now that we're approximately one-third through the season, the proof is in the pudding. 

Before you go blasting me about giving Pryor a chance over Palmer, let me make one thing clear: Palmer has been better than good. In fact, he's been better than I thought was possible when the Raiders traded for him last year. 

So why am I advocating a change? 

Palmer Isn't the Quarterback of the Future, but Pryor Might Be

Justin Edmonds/Getty Images

Palmer is 32 years old, and his best days are far behind him. 

Furthermore, he's a pure volume passer whose arm strength doesn't allow the Raiders to stretch the field as much as if a young gun like Pryor were behind center. 

With Palmer, this team is competitive, but it's not winning. 

Pryor isn't going to somehow turn the Raiders into a winning football team, but I don't believe Raiders will win more than four games this season, regardless of which quarterback is behind center. 

The Raiders need to determine whether or not Pryor has the talent, leadership and football IQ to be the quarterback of the future. If he's not, then McKenzie needs to seriously consider taking a quarterback next April. 

It's not like he hasn't shown promise, either. In limited action this preseason, Pryor completed 19-of-32 passes (59.4 percent) for 251 yards (7.8 yards per attempt) with two touchdowns and one interception (passer rating of 92.1) and ran for another 121 yards on 14 carries with one touchdown. 

The only way to determine Pryor's worth is to throw him into the fire. 

Is it time to see what the kid's got?

Submit Vote vote to see results

What's the worst thing that could happen? The Raiders find out he's not the quarterback of the future and let Palmer continue to be the stop-gap quarterback until they draft his replacement. 

There's always a chance the Raiders catch lightning in a bottle and Pryor turns out to be just as explosive as Cam Newton was for the Carolina Panthers last year. 

The 2012 season is a lost cause, but allowing Pryor to prove or disprove his worth is a worthy investment into the future of this team. 

Follow me on Twitter @JesseReed78 and check out my weekly NFL picks at

Follow Oakland Raiders from B/R on Facebook

Follow Oakland Raiders from B/R on Facebook and get the latest updates straight to your newsfeed!

Oakland Raiders

Subscribe Now

By signing up for our newsletter, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Thanks for signing up.