Fans and media alike disagree on many things when it comes to the Giants. Some think Ramses Barden should play over Domenik Hixon. Others argue whether Osi Umenyiora is an impact player or just an overrated, one-trick sack pony.
If he stinks up the joint, New York can lose to the worst team in the league—yes, even to the Browns at home this Sunday.
Through a quarter of the 2012 season, Manning has been effective and it shows in the Giants' record. Despite numerous injuries to the receiving corps and secondary, the Giants are likely one bad play call and offensive pass interference away from being 3-1.
Eli is notorious for getting off to a good start. Because of this, his statistics don't really stand out from his first four games in any of his other previous seven full seasons as noted in the chart below—his 2004 rookie year is excluded because he didn't play his first full game until Week 10 that season:
These stats don't tell the whole story, though, because they don't break down his game-to-game performance. Unlike past starts to the season, Manning has been ultra-consistent so far in 2012.
He has yet to have a game where his quarterback rating is under 85.
The only other year he accomplished this feat was 2009 when he managed to have a QB rating of at least 90 through his first four starts.
When you really think about it, Eli only played poorly in the second quarter of the Bucs game—when he tossed three interceptions—and on one terrible throw that was intercepted by the Eagles' Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie in Philadelphia's end zone at the beginning of the 4th quarter of last week's game.
How would you grade Eli Manning's performance this season?
That defeat falls squarely on bad offensive and defensive line play and terrible coverage on deep throws in the secondary.
Overall, Manning's performance this season deserves an A-. The four interceptions are the only thing keeping him from an A+.
The Dallas game was the only game this season that Eli had his full complement of receivers. When the Giants receiving corps is back at full strength, he should get some help in the games ahead—and Manning's consistent play will have to continue because Big Blue's schedule gets a lot tougher after the Cleveland matchup.