Peyton Manning: Did the Colts Make the Right Call on Him?

Nate Dunlevy@NateDunlevyGuest ColumnistSeptember 12, 2012

It was a difficult decision.
It was a difficult decision.Joey Foley/Getty Images

The catcalls have already started to flood in from angry fans.

After Peyton Manning's incredible performance against Pittsburgh, fans who feel betrayed by the Colts and by the local media have begun to voice their displeasure that Manning is playing in orange and not blue.

In the article of the day, Bob Kravitz of the Indianapolis Star says Jim Irsay was right to release Manning because in three years Manning will retire and Andrew Luck will be hitting his prime.

The Colts made one of the only two choices they could when they parted ways with Manning. What they did was absolutely defensible at the time. They couldn't carry both quarterbacks, and they chose the younger, healthier option.

It's difficult to argue with that. On the other hand, it's equally difficult to defend that in light of his apparent good health and the return of his Hall-of-Fame form.

It was an impossible choice, and Irsay made a good call. But had they kept Manning and dealt the Luck pick, that could have worked out as well.

Criticizing Irsay for the decision he made doesn't make a lot sense. He had to do something.

Having said that, it's impossible to blame fans who felt a special bond with Manning for feeling betrayed. Many in Indianapolis feel the privilege of watching his final years was taken away from them, and they would gladly have traded 10 years of Luck for a few more with Manning. They tolerated it at the time because they were told Manning wasn't healthy.

Turns out he is.


While there's no possible way to settle the dispute now, the backlash Kravitz in particular is feeling from locals is due in part to his near-incessant criticism of the Colts during the entire Manning era. He now preaches patience for a new regime to whom fans feel no allegiance, but showed none toward Tony Dungy and Bill Polian.

The new Colts regime is on the clock. They will be given a pass in 2012 because of the state of the roster, but patience will run out if the team doesn't show real improvement and contend for the playoffs in 2013.

Every game Manning plays turns up the heat on the Colts in Indianapolis.


General Interest

Scott Kacsmar of Cold Hard Football Facts runs his weekly comeback list.

Bleacher Report lead writers share their Week 2 picks. I was 13-3 last week.

Vince Verhei of the Football Outsiders posts Quick Reads.

Ryan Riddle of Bleacher Report talks about the line between hurting and injuring a player.

Jack Moore of Advanced NFL Stats looks at just how good Peyton Manning was.

Aaron Schatz of the Football Outsiders posts new DVOA and playoff odds.

Brian Burke of the Washington Post says the preseason numbers provide no insight into how rookies will play.



Tennessee Titans

Tom Gower of Total Titans dismantles Chris Johnson's running performance.

Peter Damilatis of Pro Football Focus breaks down the Titans and Patriots.

John Glennon of The Tennessean says Mike Munchak thinks Kenny Britt can help against San Diego.

Glennon asks five questions of Jason McCourty.


Jacksonville Jaguars

Sam Monson of Pro Football Focus looks at the Jaguars and Vikings.

Gene Frenette of the Florida Times-Union says Josh Scobee doesn't deserve blame for the loss.

Ryan O'Halloran of the Florida Times-Union says the Jaguars need flow on offense.


Indianapolis Colts

Kyle Rodriguez of Colts Authority says the Indy secondary was terrible.

Phil Wilson of the Indianapolis Star looks at impressive debuts by Coby Fleener and Jerrell Freeman.

Paul Kuharsky of says Indy has options at tackle.

Michael Renner of ProFootball Focus breaks down the Colts and Bears.


Houston Texans

Ben Stockwell of Pro Football Focus looks at the Dolphins and Texans.

John McClain of the Houston Chronicle says the Texans shouldn't fall for the trap of the Jaguars.

Tania Ganguli of the Houston Chronicle says Justin Blackmon will be hard for Johnathan Joseph to handle.


    Bills' Zay Jones Arrested After Bizarre Incident

    NFL logo

    Bills' Zay Jones Arrested After Bizarre Incident

    Alec Nathan
    via Bleacher Report

    Ideal Team Fits for Draft's Top QBs

    NFL logo

    Ideal Team Fits for Draft's Top QBs

    Kristopher Knox
    via Bleacher Report

    NFL Changing Controversial Catch Rule

    NFL logo

    NFL Changing Controversial Catch Rule

    Mike Chiari
    via Bleacher Report

    Barkley Is Spiraling in QB-Obsessed Draft

    NFL logo

    Barkley Is Spiraling in QB-Obsessed Draft

    Mike Tanier
    via Bleacher Report