Start 'Em, Sit 'Em Week 1: Last-Minute Advice for NFL Fantasy Football Owners

By (Featured Columnist) on September 9, 2012

45,932 reads

144Icon_comment

Previous
1 of 24
Next
Hi-res-151169639_crop_650x440
Otto Greule Jr/Getty Images

The meat of the fantasy football week is here as a full platter of NFL action is mere hours away.

Last week I gave you a head start on start/sit advice for fantasy football owners. A lot has happened even since then, but much of that still applies for Sunday's games.

Here is some last-minute start/sit advice for anyone on the fence about some of these players.

Start: Jake Locker

Hi-res-151171516_display_image
Joe Murphy/Getty Images

Jake Locker gets a tough test as the newly minted starter for the Titans.

New England is bound to put Tennessee in a hole early, meaning Locker will eventually be forced to drop back more often than not. Considering he scored 0.65 points per dropback last season—albeit in a highly limited sample size—he could be in for a nice fantasy day.

The Patriots also gave up a ton of fantasy points to opposing quarterbacks last season, though they hope to have remedied that this offseason.

Sit: Joe Flacco

Hi-res-150697653_display_image
Patrick Smith/Getty Images

Joe Flacco's best career finish was 11th in fantasy scoring. He is a middling fantasy player despite some of the weapons he has had at his disposal in recent years.

Torrey Smith is coming into his own as a serious receiving threat for Flacco and the Ravens, but his ascendancy is coming amid Anquan Boldin's decline.

Not to mention that Ray Rice has run amok against the Bengals, so the Ravens might not be passing much anyway.

Start: Stevan Ridley

Hi-res-150080111_display_image
Jim Rogash/Getty Images

Never trust a Bill Belichick running back.

That is, of course, unless his main competition for playing time is out with an injury and Belichick looks ready to put a big workload on him, right?

Stevan Ridley's biggest obstacle this week will be himself—if he fumbles early, fantasy owners could be looking at a big goose egg with Danny Woodhead exploding for 25 points.

Risk aside, Ridley looks like he will garner the bulk of the playing time in an explosive offense.

Think 2011 BenJarvus Green-Ellis, only with upside.

Sit: Trent Richardson

Hi-res-6418386_display_image
David Richard-US PRESSWIRE

The third overall pick in the draft got off to a rocky start in Cleveland, requiring knee surgery before he really got going.

He has recovered from arthroscopic surgery and looks ready to go in Week 1, but how much playing time he will get is anybody's guess. His effectiveness is a bigger question, as the Philadelphia Eagles feature an improved front seven. 

The Browns could be playing from behind early as well, which will further mitigate Trent Richardson's presence. If you have better options at RB2, play them.

Start: Brent Celek

Hi-res-150705873_display_image
Matt Sullivan/Getty Images

Would you be interested in starting the fourth-best fantasy tight end over the final 11 weeks of the 2011 regular season?

That man is Brent Celek, who has gained Michael Vick's trust and is his favorite red-zone target. With defenses focused on Vick, LeSean McCoy and DeSean Jackson, Celek is a good bet to see some throws go his way.

Sit: Jermichael Finley

Hi-res-137118845_display_image
Jamie Squire/Getty Images

If you have no comparable backup, Jermichael Finley is your starter. If you drafted a guy like, say, Brent Celek, you might want to consider benching Finley for Week 1.

The big tight end faces a good San Francisco defense this week, and he has never been a consistent producer.

Start: Donald Brown

Hi-res-150739119_display_image
Patrick McDermott/Getty Images

True, Indianapolis will be running into the teeth of a Bears defense that gave up the fourth-fewest fantasy points to running backs last season.

But Chicago will be without a fully healthy Brian Urlacher, and Donald Brown will be the horse on the Colts for the foreseeable future.

Even though Andrew Luck has not looked like a rookie, the Colts might game plan to protect him by running the ball early and often. Of course, once the Bears take a big lead, all bets are off.

As RB3s go, however, Brown is not a bad choice.

Sit: Marshawn Lynch

Hi-res-150525706_display_image
Justin Edmonds/Getty Images

Marshawn Lynch has been bothered by back spasms for almost two weeks now, and his status going into Sunday was unclear until late in the week.

He looks to be on track to play, but there is no telling how much he will be able to give. With Robert Turbin ready to roll, Lynch's workload could be compromised for multiple reasons.

Normally, he is a must-start, but it would be wise to wait and see if you have comparable options.

Start: Vincent Jackson

Hi-res-6444838_display_image
Kim Klement-US PRESSWIRE

His former San Diego teammate Philip Rivers isn't throwing him the football anymore, but Vincent Jackson is now the man at receiver for the Buccaneers.

He might not be putting up WR1 numbers this season, but he is still serviceable as a WR2 or flex play, despite Tampa Bay's penchant for running the football.

Sit: Steve Johnson

Hi-res-136524189_display_image
Jim Rogash/Getty Images

The Bills' star receiver has been battling a groin injury, landing him on the "questionable" list heading into the weekend. 

He should be fine, but not his fantasy output.

For some reason, there is a notion that Steve Johnson has escaped Revis Island. Considering he has averaged just 47.2 yards per game against the stud cornerback, it is safe to say that one good game last season was more aberration than liberation.

Start: Ronnie Brown

Hi-res-150710170_display_image
Hannah Foslien/Getty Images

Ryan Mathews was unsurprisingly declared out of Monday's matchup with the Raiders just weeks after breaking his clavicle.

That means Ronnie Brown should carry the load for the Chargers, at least until Mathews' return or Brown's ineffectiveness finally prompts a change.

The reality is that Brown should have decent RB3 numbers at the very least, though Curtis Brinkley could get in the way at the goal line. His plodding nature taken into consideration, Brown is a better fantasy starter in Week 1 than...

Sit: Adrian Peterson

Hi-res-150714443_display_image
Hannah Foslien/Getty Images

All Day will get lucky to get in on a few plays this weekend.

He has had a remarkable recovery, and his determination to be ready for Week 1 is admirable. His goal and reality do not entirely mesh, however.

Consider Rashard Mendenhall, who had a less severe knee injury just one week after Adrian Peterson shredded his MCL and ACL on Christmas Eve in 2011. Mendenhall, too, is practicing, but Pittsburgh is wisely holding him out this weekend.

(Mendy is officially "doubtful," but we all know what that means.)

The Vikings would be foolish to let Peterson on the field at all, but he could talk his way into a few plays. He is not worth the risk until he proves he can handle more than a few snaps.

Start: Russell Wilson

Hi-res-151171662_display_image
Otto Greule Jr/Getty Images

He is not going to have a Cam Newton-like debut, but Russell Wilson is one of those fantasy gambles worth taking in Week 1.

Wilson's ability to score points with his legs will be on full display in Week 1. He might not get into the end zone, but the rookie has fantastic athleticism and escapability—he should break a few good runs to go with his passing statistics.

Granted, you should not start him over, say, Jay Cutler, but he should be in your lineup over...

Sit: Andrew Luck

Hi-res-151012560_display_image
Andy Lyons/Getty Images

Andrew Luck gets dropped into a hot zone to start his career, opening up against a good Chicago defense on the road. He will have to contend with a ferocious defensive line led by Julius Peppers and a raucous crowd.

He may have looked the part of a No. 1 overall pick in the preseason, but his first regular-season test could prove too difficult for him to pass from a fantasy standpoint.

Start: Nate Washington

Hi-res-150657470_display_image
Frederick Breedon/Getty Images

Kenny Britt exploded onto the fantasy scene last season, posting fantastic numbers in his first two games. Then he tore his knee up in Week 3, opening the door for Nate Washington to perform.

He did not quite post fantasy scores like Britt's, but Washington was quietly the 15th-best fantasy receiver over the final 14 games of the season. 

Britt is out via suspension this week, opening up that door one more time for Washington. 

Sit: Santonio Holmes

Hi-res-150872111_display_image
Jeff Zelevansky/Getty Images

Santonio Holmes might be the Jets' only offensive weapon—you know, unless you consider Tim Tebow's 10 percent participation—but that does not mean he will be a good fantasy option.

The mercurial receiver was just 31st in fantasy scoring last season in a similar situation, and the Jets offense might be going backward. 

Start: Michael Crabtree

Hi-res-142633241_display_image
Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

This one is for deep-leaguers.

Michael Crabtree has been a disappointment for the 49ers since he diva'd his way into the league. He has never lived up to his first-round status, failing to reach his potential with Alex Smith at the helm.

Now that San Francisco has Randy Moss and Mario Manningham, will Crabtree be better off? The bet here is "yes," as Moss will take the top off defenses, which will also have to contend with the likes of Vernon Davis.

Plus, the 49ers might be playing catch-up against the Packers, and Crabtree will be a big part of that.

Sit: Randy Moss

Hi-res-6534906_display_image
Kelley L Cox-US PRESSWIRE

By all accounts, Randy Moss, 35, has not lost much of his speed. But have his skills deteriorated with age?

Indeed, Moss will be starting in Week 1, but his fantasy value is nebulous until he can prove he's still got it. After all, the last time we saw Moss, he was bouncing around the league looking like a washed-up veteran.

Start: DeAngelo Williams

Hi-res-150552772_display_image
Streeter Lecka/Getty Images

Jonathan Stewart is ailing, officially questionable this Sunday against Tampa Bay with a balky ankle. If the Panthers are wise, they will let Stewart rest as much as possible to get him fully healthy.

That is good news for DeAngelo Williams' fantasy value.

Even though Cam Newton and Mike Tolbert are the big threats to take goal-line work, D-Will should see a good workload. The Bucs did not exactly excel at stopping the run last season, but that may not matter with a new regime in town.

Sit: Beanie Wells

Hi-res-136109537_display_image
Christian Petersen/Getty Images

Beanie Wells spent all offseason recovering from relatively minor knee surgery, then he injured his hamstring in practice at the end of the preseason.

The Cardinals expect Wells to start on Sunday, but he has Ryan Williams nipping at his heels. Arizona plays a good Seattle defense as well.

At this point, neither back is really a strong starter until one establishes himself. Wells has battled injuries throughout his career, and Williams has yet to prove himself at this level after a major injury of his own.

Start at your own risk.

Start: Brandon Pettigrew

Hi-res-136433312_display_image
Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images

The Rams have a tough test against the Lions at home this week, and they will likely try to scheme against Calvin Johnson, starting with some off-the-field gamesmanship (per The Detroit News).

They know they can't stop Megatron—they can only hope to slow him down—but on those occasional plays where the defense takes Johnson away, Brandon Pettigrew will be there to clean up.

He is also a big red-zone target for Stafford.

Start with confidence.

Sit: Tony Gonzalez

Hi-res-150406768_display_image
Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images

It's not that Tony Gonzalez is a bad fantasy option—if he is your No. 1 tight end without a comparable No. 2, he should be in your lineup—but the 36-year-old could have a tough time against Eric Berry and the Kansas City defense.

Julio Jones and Roddy White are also taking targets away from the grizzled veteran.

 

Twitter Button

Begin Slideshow
Keep Reading
Flag
Props (0)
This article is

What is the duplicate article?

Why is this article offensive?

Where is this article plagiarized from?

Why is this article poorly edited?

Flag This Article
Default-user-icon-comment
or to post a comment

144 Comments

There are no comments yet. Get the conversation started by leaving the first comment
Big
Loading comments...
just now posted just now
  • Loading...
  • Nobody has liked this comment yet
Cancel

This comment and all replies have been deleted This comment has been deleted Undo delete

Follow B/R on Facebook

Fans of

Icon_subscribe
Icon_youtube
Icon_google
NFL

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address

Thanks for signing up.

We're Scouting Top Writers

Buy or Sell Each Team's Odds of Improving Win Total Hint: you can use arrow keys to navigate through this channel.