Rashard Mendenhall: Complete Fantasy Profile & Draft Strategy

Tyler Conway@jtylerconwayFeatured ColumnistSeptember 2, 2012

KANSAS CITY, MO - NOVEMBER 27:  Rashard Mendenhall #34 of the Pittsburgh Steelers carries the ball during the game against the Kansas City Chiefs on November 27, 2011 at Arrowhead Stadium in Kansas City, Missouri.  (Photo by Jamie Squire/Getty Images)
Jamie Squire/Getty Images

With just a few days remaining until the New York Giants and Dallas Cowboys kick off the 2012 NFL season on Sept. 5, it's crunch time for fantasy football owners across the world. 

And one of the players with the most questions surrounding his status heading into fantasy drafts this season is Pittsburgh Steelers running back Rashard Mendenhall

The 25-year-old back struggled throughout much of 2011, going over the 100-yard plateau just twice while failing to reach 1,000 yards for the first time as the primary rusher. Nevertheless, it's how Mendenhall's season ended that gives the most pause to fantasy owners for 2012.

In the regular season's final game against the Cleveland Browns, Mendenall tore his ACL and has yet to be cleared for full contact.

With Mendanhall activated but doubtful for the Steelers' Week 1 contest (via ESPN), we're here to give you everything you'll need to know about the Pittsburgh back headed into your fantasy draft.


What Round Should You Take Mendenhall?

According to ESPN.com's live draft results, you may not even have to take Mendenhall at all, depending on the size of your league.

With an average draft position of 136.3, Mendenhall is currently a 12th-round pick in 12-team leagues and a 14th-rounder in 10-teamers. Nevertheless, Mendenhall is only owned in 53.6 percent of standard leagues. If your league is particularly averse to injury-prone players, the Steelers running back may even last until the waiver wire. 

Luckily for you, that means you will have plenty of time to draft reliable starters before considering Mendenhall. If you think he'll be effective when he gets back, the Pittsburgh back could be a perfect player to stash on the bench.


Injury Assessment/Latest News

Though Mendenhall was in uniform for the Steelers' last preseason game against the Carolina Panthers, he had no shot of playing and is still practicing on a limited basis (via the Beaver County Times). 

Running backs coming back from ACL tears are always dicey, as Mendenhall is far more prone to hurting his knee than ever before. Throughout history we have seen even the best rushers in the league lose their legendary explosion due to the devastating injury. 

As it currently stands, I wouldn't expect to see Mendenhall on the field before October. He's too valuable to the Steelers going forward and it's not worth risking his career to put him in before he's 100 percent. 


Season Projection

Even if Mendenhall somehow makes it back to the field in September, he won't be fully healthy. With that in mind, it's likely that Pittsburgh head coach Mike Tomlin will limit his carries accordingly.

Isaac Redman and Jonathan Dwyer are both serviceable replacements who give the Steelers comfort in allowing Mendenhall to heal as much as possible. 

I wouldn't expect to see the fifth-year back start any more than 10 contests, and with the team trying to lighten his workload, getting to 500 yards would be a godsend. 

Projected Stats: 500 total yards, four touchdowns


Bye Week

The Steelers have a Week 4 bye, so that could mean Mendenhall misses just the first three games of the season. That can only mean good things if you're high on Mendenhall for when he comes back.

If you want Mendy, that bye week could give him a full extra round of value for you.


Split Situation

Isaac Redman was exemplary in the Steelers' backup role in 2011 and is the favorite to takeover the primary workload while Mendenhall sits out.

That all was expected.

However, the emergence of Jonathan Dwyer in the preseason throws a huge monkey wrench into the entire Pittsburgh running back situation. The former Georgia Tech back has impressed Tomlin throughout camp and played well enough in the exhibition season to get a significant look early in 2012. 

If Dwyer or Redman has a particularly strong start to the season, Mendenhall may never reclaim his starting spot.

At the very least, it's a fluid situation that should be paid attention to by all Mendenhall owners. 


Players to Take Before Rashard Mendenhall

Considering Mendenhall is currently the 48th running back being taken in ESPN.com standard leagues, the pickings are rather slim that late in the draft.

Nevertheless, there are still a couple late-bloomers I would rather take a shot on. Redskins head coach Mike Shanahan seemingly picks a new running back a week, so both Alfred Morris and Evan Royster are worthy of a flier. 

In addition, post-hype sleeper Mikel Leshoure could be the steal of your entire draft if Detroit Lions starter Kevin Smith goes down with injury. 


Players to Take After Rashard Mendenhall

Again, at this stage of the draft, you're looking to take a shot and strike gold. Regardless, I would still rather have Mendenhall than Pierre Thomas, James Starks and Shane Vereen, all guys going ahead of or in the same area as the Steelers back. 

Even with the knee injury hampering his value, Mendenhall at 60 percent will almost surely have more fantasy value than each of those guys listed. 



If you can get Mendenhall in rounds 12-15, he could become one of the biggest late-round values in 2012. 

However, the uncertainty surrounding his knee injury and the Steelers running-back situation are both huge risk factors. 

If there is a voracious Steelers fan in your league who wants to grab the Pittsburgh back earlier than his current value, pass him up and don't think twice. 



    Biggest Non-Draft Storylines to Watch at the Combine

    NFL logo

    Biggest Non-Draft Storylines to Watch at the Combine

    Brad Gagnon
    via Bleacher Report

    Prospects with Most to Prove at 2018 Combine

    NFL logo

    Prospects with Most to Prove at 2018 Combine

    Justis Mosqueda
    via Bleacher Report

    Current NFL Stars Who Dominated Their Combine

    NFL logo

    Current NFL Stars Who Dominated Their Combine

    Gary Davenport
    via Bleacher Report

    The 'Lesson of Tebow' Still Haunts the Combine

    Pittsburgh Steelers logo
    Pittsburgh Steelers

    The 'Lesson of Tebow' Still Haunts the Combine

    Mike Freeman
    via Bleacher Report