Will GSP's Legacy Be Incomplete If He Never Fights Anderson Silva?

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Will GSP's Legacy Be Incomplete If He Never Fights Anderson Silva?
Jeff Zelevansky/Getty Images

It has been several years since the first time a Georges St-Pierre vs. Anderson Silva superfight has been brought up. To be honest, it has felt like a decade.

Fans are infatuated by a showdown between the Canadian star and Brazilian juggernaut, and for good reason. Both men have cleared out their divisions for the most part.

So the question is, would St-Pierre's legacy be incomplete if he never fights the Brazilian legend?

To be fair, the question could go for Anderson Silva too, had he ever lost in the UFC.

St-Pierre has dominated the 170-pound weight class in a way similar to Silva's domination of the 185-pound division.

Both are so dominant, they rarely lose rounds. I mean, when was the last time either lost a round?

For Silva, it feels the only time he has ever lost a round in the UFC was when he fought Chael Sonnen. St-Pierre's only lost rounds as of late came as a result of an savage eye poke against Jake Shields, though he still won the fight.

St-Pierre's legacy goes as follows: Establish dominance in the regionals, impress in your first couple UFC fights, earn a title shot against the legendary Matt Hughes in your young career, lose that title fight and come back stronger.

After that, go on a big winning streak against top competition, earn another title shot against Matt Hughes, win the rematch and get upset in your first defense against a career journeyman.

So what do you think?

Submit Vote vote to see results

The final phase of St-Pierre's legacy sees him win a rubber match with Hughes, get back his title in a revenge fight with aforementioned journeyman and never look back.

That's right; since winning his title back, he has won six fights in a row—all of which have been against the cream of the crop at welterweight.

St-Pierre is a legend at welterweight, whether fans like him or not. Sure, his fight style has gotten a little safe as of late, but his dominance is unquestioned.

Yes, a fight with Silva would be epic. And yes, win or lose, it would still be great for his reputation.

But, in my eyes, St-Pierre doesn't need this fight to complete his legacy. It is already set in stone, as he is the most dominant welterweight of all time.

I still want to see the fight, as the divisions are basically cleared out. Once St-Pierre fights Carlos Condit and Silva fights Chris Weidman, I think the time is right to let them fight. 

It would further their already legendary reputations. 

Countdown Clock

Out of Bounds


Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address

Thanks for signing up.