College Football Playoff Rewind: 2006 Four-Team Playoff

Jake WestrichSenior Writer IAugust 1, 2012

BATON ROUGE, LA - SEPTEMBER 02:  Head Coach Les Miles of Louisiana State University (C) celebrates with his team after defeating the University of Louisiana - Lafayette 45-3 on September 2, 2006 at Tiger Stadium in Baton Rouge, Louisiana.  (Photo by Chris Graythen/Getty Images)
Chris Graythen/Getty Images

To amend a quote by Benjamin Franklin: "In this world nothing can be said to be certain, except death, taxes and BCS controversies."

The 2006 college football season was no different, as a handful of teams clamored to join undefeated Ohio State in the BCS Championship game. Boise State (12-0), Louisville (11-1) and Wisconsin (11-1) made solid arguments, but Michigan was the biggest slight, as Florida edged out the Wolverines by a mere .0101 points in the final BCS standings.

Florida's only blemish on the season was a 27-17 defeat at Auburn, and the team's SEC championship win over Arkansas helped the Gators leapfrog Michigan in the final BCS standings, moving from No. 4 to No. 2. Michigan's lone loss came in its last regular-season game, a gut-wrenching 42-39 setback to Ohio State in Columbus.

With the help of our college football simulation engine, we're rewriting history and offering Michigan a shot at redemption by placing the Wolverines in a four-team national championship playoff. Ohio State and Florida secure the top seeds, while LSU joins the fictional fray in the fourth and final spot.

The Tigers lost to Auburn and Florida in the season's early going but put together six consecutive wins to earn the No. 4 ranking in the final BCS standings and, more importantly, admission into our tournament.

Playoff seeding based on BCS rankings.

2006 College Football Semifinal
Matchup Win% Avg Score WIS Interactive
(1) Ohio State 41.4 23.0 Simulate Game
(4) LSU 58.6 26.2


2006 Ohio State
Record: 12-1 (National Championship loss)
Team MVP: Troy Smith
(2,542 pass yards / 30 TDs)

2006 LSU
Record: 11-2 (Sugar Bowl win)
Team MVP: JaMarcus Russell
(3,129 pass yards / 28 TDs)


2006 College Football Semifinal
Matchup Win% Avg Score WIS Interactive
(2) Florida 45.3 20.7 Simulate Game
(3) Michigan 54.7 22.0


2006 Florida
Record: 13-1 (National Champions)
Team MVP: Chris Leak
(2,950 pass yards / 23 TDs)

2006 Michigan
Record: 12-2 (Rose Bowl loss)
Team MVP: Mike Hart
(1,562 rush yards / 14 TDs)


2006 College Football Title Game
Matchup Win% Avg Score WIS Interactive
(3) Michigan 43.9 21.7 Simulate Game
(4) LSU 56.1 24.3 Sample Boxscore


Simulated Title Game: Recap


Playoff proponents are sure to like our semifinal upsets, as No. 1 Ohio State couldn't handle the SEC speed of LSU, while Michigan made the most of its second chance by narrowly edging out Florida.

Despite being two of the more historic programs in college football, Michigan and LSU have never met on the gridiron. That all changed as the two schools clashed for the ultimate prize: a BCS Playoff Championship.

LSU won the coin toss and elected to receive, a move that quickly paid dividends. On the second play of the game, Keiland Williams took a handoff 63 yards before being chased down at the four-yard line. Backup rusher Justin Vincent made no progress on two runs, and a pass from JaMarcus Russell to Jacob Hester fell incomplete, forcing the Tigers to settle for a chip-shot field goal by Colt David.

Michigan responded with two field goals of its own behind kicker Garrett Rivas, and the Wolverines held a 6-3 lead as the first quarter expired.

The advantage didn't last long as Russell began picking apart the Michigan secondary. He completed three consecutive passes—a 24-yard strike to Dwayne Bowe, a 16-yard gain to Early Doucet and a touchdown pass to Craig "Buster" Davis from eights yards out—for LSU's first touchdown and a 10-6 lead.

Later in the quarter, Russell found Brandon LaFell for a 19-yard gain on third and long. He hit LaFell again on the ensuing play for his second touchdown pass of the game.

With just one minute remaining in the half, the Wolverines quickly went to work. Running back Mike Hart churned for 15 yards, and Chad Henne connected with Mario Manningham, Tyler Ecker and Steve Breaston for several big plays. The drive finally stalled at the LSU 19-yard line and Rivas punched in his third field goal to keep Michigan within striking distance, trailing 9-17 at the half.

Rivas added his fourth and fifth field goals in the third quarter, but Michigan lost ground, surrendering seven points to the Tigers as Russell again found Davis in the end zone.

Hart got things moving for the Wolverines in the fourth quarter, as his 57-yard run brought Michigan to the LSU five-yard line. Henne then zipped a short pass to Ecker, and suddenly LSU's lead dwindled to 24-22 with more than 12 minutes remaining in the game.

Both teams hit a stall, trading punts before Michigan finally got to work around the three-minute mark. Henne found Breaston in the open field, and he sped to the LSU 31-yard line. The Wolverines were just a 48-yard field goal from the win, but the distance matched Rivas's longest of the season, and two-and-a-half minutes remained to improve field position.

Brandon Minor's rush resulted in a two-yard loss and Henne's pass to Carson Butler only got back to the line of scrimmage. On third down, Henne was sacked for a six-yard loss.

Instead of improving its field position, Michigan was forced to let Rivas try from 56 yards out. His kick had the distance but sailed wide right.

The Tigers ran out the remaining minute to hold on for the 24-22 win.