MLB: Do Second Basemen Make the Best Managers?

Jerry Tapp@@StatsonTappSenior Analyst IIIMay 17, 2012

Buck Showalter
Buck ShowalterJamie Squire/Getty Images

Baltimore Orioles skipper Buck Showalter, earlier this season, became the 58th manager in major league history to win 1,000 or more games in the major leagues. The 56-year-old Showalter, who previously managed the New York Yankees, Arizona Diamondbacks and Texas Rangers, has the Orioles in a tie for first place in the American League East race.

Of those 58 managers with 1,000-plus wins, 51 also played in the majors. Showalter is one of the seven men who did not play in the majors.

So here’s the question: What position has "birthed" the most 1,000-win managers in the majors?

Second basemen top the list with 11.

Recently-retired skipper Tony LaRussa played second base in the "bigs" and tops the list of second basemen turned managers with the most wins: 2,728. LaRussa stands third on the all-time list of wins by a manager behind Connie Mack (a catcher) and John McGraw (a third baseman).

Following are the number of managers, by position, who have won 1,000 or more games. Also listed is the manager who has won the most games at each position.

Position, Number of Managers with 1,000 wins, Most wins

Tony LaRussa
Tony LaRussaPool/Getty Images

Second Basemen, 11 (Tony LaRussa, 2,728)

Catchers, 8 (Connie Mack, 3,731)

Shortstops, 6 (Leo Durocher, 2,008)

Third Basemen, 6 (John McGraw, 2,763)

First Basemen, 6 (Walter Alston, 2,040)

Left Fielders, 5 (Lou Piniella, 1,835)

Right Fielders, 5 (Casey Stengel, 1,905)

Pitchers, 2 (Tommy Lasorda, 1,599)

Center Fielders, 2 (Ned Hanlon, 1,313)

Here’s a look at the seven managers with 1,000 or more wins who did not play in the majors:

Joe McCarthy, 2,215

Jim Leyland, 1,606 *

Earl Weaver, 1,480

Frank Selee, 1,284

Jim Leyland
Jim LeylandThearon W. Henderson/Getty Images

John McNamara, 1,160

Jack McKeon, 1,051

Buck Showalter, 1009


If you take a look at the 30 managers now leading clubs in the majors, 24 played in the majors. Six of the 30 managers were catchers. Another interesting note is that every position is represented in the 24 managers who played in the majors.

Here’s a breakdown of today’s 30 managers and the positions they played in the majors. Also noted are the six current managers who did not play major league baseball.

First Base: Don Mattingly

Second Base: Davey Johnson, Ron Washington

Shortstop: Bobby Valentine, Ron Gardenhire, Ozzie Guillen, Dale Sveum

Third Base: Brad Mills, Robin Ventura

Left Field: Dusty Baker, Charlie Manuel, Jim Tracy, Kirk Gibson

Center Field: Ron Roenicke

Don Mattingly
Don MattinglyStephen Dunn/Getty Images

Right Field: Clint Hurdle

Catcher: Bruce Bochy, Mike Scioscia, Bob Melvin, Ned Yost, Joe Girardi, Mike Matheny

Pitcher: Bud Black, John Farrell

Designated Hitter: Eric Wedge


Did not play in the majors: Jim Leyland, Buck Showalter, Terry Collins, Joe Maddon, Manny Acta, Fredi Gonzalez.


Follow Jerry on Twitter @StatsonTapp


    Report: Twins to Sign 1B Logan Morrison

    MLB logo

    Report: Twins to Sign 1B Logan Morrison

    Adam Wells
    via Bleacher Report

    Yankees Add A-Rod, Matsui, Reggie Jackson as Special Advisors

    MLB logo

    Yankees Add A-Rod, Matsui, Reggie Jackson as Special Advisors

    Timothy Rapp
    via Bleacher Report

    Why the Players Need to Own MLB's Pace-of-Play Problem

    MLB logo

    Why the Players Need to Own MLB's Pace-of-Play Problem

    Buster Olney

    Ohtani Surrenders HR, Strikes Out 2 in Debut

    MLB logo

    Ohtani Surrenders HR, Strikes Out 2 in Debut

    Mike Chiari
    via Bleacher Report