That is backwards, but that can also backfire because there could be football players dream to play at BYU, and they may be ok but not great players. These guys would give anything to play for BYU, since it was their dream.
This is not to say BYU coaches do not go on the recruiting trail to scout players, but it seems that they want these high school players to seek out BYU and not the other way. The quote below puts this in perspective of coach Bronco Mendenhall’s recruiting style:
“Players that want to be coddled and want to be catered to don’t come, and some are good LDS players. We want them to be passionate about the chance to play at BYU. I really don’t have much time for those that want to be convinced.
“I think it’s degrading as a coach to try to convince an 18-year-old young man why he should come to your place. I know that’s contrary to most recruiting thoughts, but I like young men that know what they want and are willing to pursue it, and they convince others of where they’re going in life.”
—BYU coach Bronco Mendenhall
This could be why BYU just lost out on the nations top linebacker and number two recruit overall, Manti Te’os. He had his visit and there are many rumors of what happened, and nothing has come out yet.
A few have been that when Manti Te’os was in town that there was a party involved with alcohol, this one has legs since two BYU players, Shiloah Te’o and O’Neil Chambers, were involved.
However, nothing was noted if Manti Te’os was involved, but the other rumor is that BYU was too much religion and overwhelmed him. Whatever the reason is BYU is off his list and it is now down to USC, UCLA, and Notre Dame.
If BYU wants to be content with winning 10 games a year, and winning the conference every other year or so, they need to go out and pursue athletes that are LDS who are highly touted and give them good treatment.
Also, they need to go after athletes that may not be LDS, but want a clean enviroment. There are great players that do not party or drink and are religious, just look at Florida’’s Tim Tebow; he is very religious.
BYU needs to get the best LDS athletes and try to get athletes who want that clean environment, and it would be ok for the staff to woo players. Follow the jump to see who has committed to BYU.
Lee Aguirre DB 5-11 200 Fullerton, CA
Jordan Atkinson LB 6-3 235
Terry Alletto OC 6-3 265 Ponderosa H.S. (CO) OC #4
Richard Wilson TE 6-3 224 Spanish Fork H.S. (UT) TE #4
Kyle Van Noy ATH 6-4 200 McQueen H.S. (NV) ATH #61
Brad Wilcox OT 6-7 265 Edmond North H.S. (OK) OT #37
Mitch Mathews WR 6-4 187 Southridge H.S. (OR) WR #122
Craig Bills S 6-2 200 Timpview H.S. (UT) S #148 74
Tui Crichton OG 6-4 280 Timpview H.S. (UT) OG #139
Remington Peck TE 6-4 212 Bingham H.S. (UT) TE #79
Trevor Bateman CB 5-10 170 Palm Desert H.S. (CA) CB #75
Adam Timo ATH 6-1 190 Snow Canyon H.S. (UT) ATH #144
Malosi Te’o RB 5-11 195 Kahuku H.S. (HI)
Peni Maka’afi FB 5-11 215 Northridge H.S. (UT) FB #34
Brett Thompson WR 6-2 200 Oak Ridge H.S. (CA) WR #190
Ryan Mulitalo OG 6-3 310 Hunter H.S. (UT) OG #219
Thomas Bryson TE 6-5 215 Layton H.S. (UT) TE #121
Jray Galea’i S 6-0 180 Kahuku H.S. (HI)
Anthony Heimuli RB 5-11 225 Mountain View H.S. (UT)
Cody Hoffman WR 6-4 200 Del Norte H.S. (CA)
Fono Vakalahi OG 6-4 320 Bryan H.S. (TX)