NFL History

Andrew Luck: Will He Become the Next Peyton Manning or JaMarcus Russell?

Andrew Luck
Andrew LuckChristian Petersen/Getty Images
Jerry TappSenior Analyst IIIApril 25, 2012

Stanford’s Andrew Luck will become the 18th quarterback taken with the first overall pick since 1970 in the NFL draft on Thursday. The Indianapolis Colts obviously hope that Luck can deliver wins and playoff victories in the same manner as the man he replaces, Peyton Manning, who was also the first overall pick in 1998.

Based on the rookie year performance of the previous QBs who were the first overall pick in the draft, what can we expect from Luck’s first season as the Colts leader?

First, based on the win-loss records of the other 17 QBs in games they started their first season, there may not be many wins to celebrate in 2012. The other 17 No. 1 picks won 55 and lost 132 for a .294 winning percentage in games they started their first season. In addition, those QBs passed for an average of 11.9 touchdowns their rookie season.

Following are the career win-loss records of the 17 quarterbacks who were the No. 1 overall pick in an NFL draft.

 

Year Drafted, Quarterback, Career W-L Record and Percentage (Rookie Year W-L Record)

1998 Peyton Manning, 141-67, .678 (3-13)

1970 Terry Bradshaw, 107-51, .677 (3-5)

1983 John Elway, 148-82, .617 (4-6)

2001 Michael Vick, 53-37-1, .588 (1-1)

2004 Eli Manning, 69-50, .580 (1-6)

1989 Troy Aikman, 94-71, .570 (0-11)

Peyton Manning
Peyton ManningDoug Pensinger/Getty Images

1993 Drew Bledsoe, 98-95, .508 (5-7)

1971 Jim Plunkett, 72-72, .500 (6-8)

2005 Alex Smith, 32-34, .485 (2-5)

2004 Carson Palmer, 50-56, .472 (0-0)

1975 Steve Bartkowski, 59-68, .465 (4-7)

2009 Matthew Stafford, 13-16, .448 (2-8)

1987 Vinny Testaverde, 90-123-1, .423 (0-4)

2011 Cam Newton, 6-10, .375 (6-10)

1999 Tim Couch, 22-37, .373 (2-12)

1990 Jeff George, 46-78, .371 (5-7)

2010 Sam Bradford, 8-18, .308 (7-9)

2003 David Carr, 23-56, .291 (4-12)

2008 JaMarcus Russell, 7-18, .280 (0-1)

 

Most TDs passes in rookie year by overall No. 1 QB

Cam Newton
Cam NewtonMike Coppola/Getty Images

26: Peyton Manning

21: Cam Newton

19: Jim Plunkett

18: Sam Bradford

16: Jeff George

 

Did you know...?

Of the 17 QBs who were the No. 1 overall pick since 1970, Sam Bradford won the most games in his rookie season with seven.

Peyton Manning lost the most games his rookie year with 13.

Michael Vick was the only QB to have a winning percentage at .500 or above in his rookie year starts; he was 1-1.

The other 16 signal-callers were all under .500 in their rookie-year starts.

 

Follow Jerry on Twitter @StatsOnTapp

Where can I comment?

Stay on your game

Latest news, insights, and forecasts on your teams across leagues.

Choose Teams
Get it on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Real-time news for your teams right on your mobile device.

Download
Copyright © 2017 Bleacher Report, Inc. Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. All Rights Reserved. BleacherReport.com is part of Bleacher Report – Turner Sports Network, part of the Turner Sports and Entertainment Network. Certain photos copyright © 2017 Getty Images. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of Getty Images is strictly prohibited. AdChoices