2012 NHL All-Star Game Mock Fantasy Draft

Jacob Born@@Jacob_BornContributor IIIJanuary 25, 2012

2012 NHL All-Star Game Mock Fantasy Draft

0 of 41

    The NHL has a very unique way of running the All-Star game. There is no East vs. West or even North America vs. World. Instead, it's Team Alfredsson vs. Team Chara.

    The NHL chooses captains to pick fantasy teams for the game, just as kids do on the pond or playground. Alfredsson has an assistant captain in Henrik Lundqvist, and Chara's assistant captain is Joffrey Lupul. 

    So, who has the better team when it's all said and done?

Team Alfredsson Round 1: Jason Spezza

1 of 41

    Alfredsson is going to get caught up in the All-Star game. While Spezza isn't the most talented forward in the draft, he has been doing a great job in Ottawa this year, and the hometown fans are going to want him on Alfredsson's team. He won't disappoint.

Team Chara Round 1: Claude Giroux

2 of 41

    Chara, on the other hand, will not fall into this trap. He picks who deserves to be the No.1 pick, Claude Giroux. He is putting up MVP numbers, and Chara knows that if he wants to win, he needs to grab Giroux.

Team Alfredsson Round 2: Evgeni Malkin

3 of 41

    Alfredsson rights the ship with this pick. Malkin has had to put Pittsburgh on his back with injuries to Sidney Crosby and Jordan Staal. Malkin has also been putting up MVP numbers as he leads the NHL in points. Really, he and Giroux are 1a and 1b. Alfredsson makes a good pick this time.

Team Chara Round 2: Pavel Datsyuk

4 of 41

    Pavel Datsyuk has arguably the best hands in the NHL. He makes moves that players can only dream of. With this pick, Chara is not only thinking of the game but also the Skills Competition. Datsyuk is a great pick for Chara to make. Offense rules the day.

Team Alfredsson Round 3: Steven Stamkos

5 of 41

    Steven Stamkos leads the NHL in goals, and the All-Star game is all about scoring (last year's game final was 11-10). Stamkos is the perfect match for Team Alfredsson to combat the scoring ability of Giroux and Datsyuk. Put him on a line with Malkin and the puck will go in for sure. 

Team Chara Round 3: Henrik Sedin

6 of 41

    This may be a stretch for Team Chara, but bear with me. We all know that Chara is not very friendly with the Sedin twins, or any Canuck for that matter, but the top line is just too much to pass up. Sedin, Datsyuk and Giroux. Sedin could set up either of those two with his eyes closed.

    This line would dominate the game even more than a normal All-Star line would.

Team Alfredsson Round 4: Daniel Sedin

7 of 41

    Alfredsson will break up the Sedin twins once again. Alfredsson will add the goal-scoring part of the Sedin tandem and it will give his team benefits. But then again, so will every all-star chosen.

Team Chara Round 4: Phil Kessel

8 of 41

    This one comes after heavy influence from assistant captain Joffrey Lupul. Kessel is having a career year for the Maple Leafs, and pairing him up with Lupul would create great chemistry on Chara's team. 

Team Alfredsson Round 5: Marion Hossa

9 of 41

    Hossa started out his career in Ottawa, playing seven seasons before leaving. He and Alfredsson were a scoring tandem that gave defenses nightmares. This pick is for them to try and get that scoring ability back and give the fans a blast from the past. 

Team Chara Round 5: Corey Perry

10 of 41

    Perry is one of the bright spots on an underachieving Anaheim team, although that may not last for long. He is the one Duck that deserves to be at the All-Star game. Chara wants to add some more forwards before having to pick some goalies.

Team Alfredsson Round 6: Shea Weber

11 of 41

    Alfredsson decides it's time to grab a defenseman, and who better than Weber? Weber is an offensive-minded defender, and he is the only player that could compete with Chara in the Hardest Shot contest in the Skills Competition. Smart pick by Alfredsson.

Team Chara Round 6: Patrick Kane

12 of 41

    Patrick Kane is a true leader on the Blackhawks team and is now the leader of the team (with Toews out). Kane knows how to score in big games (Stanley Cup Finals Game 6) and will do so for Chara in the All-Star game. Chara is bringing out the big guns to win this game. 

Team Alfredsson Round 7: Marian Gaborik

13 of 41

    Assistant captain Lundqvist had some help bringing Gaborik onto the team, but it's a smart pick. Gaborik is Datsyuk-ian in the sense that he too has some very good hands that can come in handy not only in the All-Star game but also the Skills Competition. These teams are getting stacked, but what else would you expect from the All-Star game?

Team Chara Round 7: Jarome Iginla

14 of 41

    Jarome Iginla is the best career player in the All-Star game this year. He recently netted his 500th career game and deserves to be picked high in the draft. Chara waited as long as he could, but now it's time to grab this steal.

Team Alfredsson Round 8: Jimmy Howard

15 of 41

    Alfredsson recognizes that Chara has to pick goalies in the next three rounds, so why not grab one before he does? With Lundqvist already on his team, Alfredsson has arguably the best two goalies in the game on his team. Even though these games are nightmares for goalies, maybe having the best two goalies can stop some of the bleeding that will occur.

Team Chara Round 8: Tim Thomas

16 of 41

    Despite what has happened in the media recently with Tim Thomas, Chara is still his teammate. Chara is not going to leave his teammate hanging and is going to make the Conn Smythe and Vezina Winner the first goalie on his team. 

Team Alfredsson Round 9: Erik Karlsson

17 of 41

    Alfredsson is getting a jump on the next round and is drafting Karlsson, another move that is sure to make the hometown crowd happy. Karlsson is having a career year with the Senators and is a big reason for where the team is, going into the All-Star break. It looks to be like the Senators vs. the All-Stars.

Team Chara Round 9: Brian Elliot

18 of 41

    This is going to be a fantastic homecoming for Elliot. Elliot is the biggest reason why the Blues currently third in the NHL. He leads the league in GAA and save percentage with 1.69 and .938, respectively. Chara makes the smart move in drafting this first-time All-Star.

Team Alfredsson Round 10: Jonathan Quick

19 of 41

    Team Alfredsson picks up their third and final goalie with Jonathan Quick. Quick is having a fantastic year, ranking fourth in GAA and save percentage, and has had his name in the running for the Vezina all year. Definitely not a bad goalie to round out the core. 

Team Chara Round 10: Carey Price

20 of 41

    Mr. Irrelevant for the goalies is anything but. Price has played solidly for the majority of the season for the Canadiens and is the right man to represent them at the All-Star game. Chara should be extremely pleased with the goalies on his team. 

Team Alfredsson Round 11: Ryan Suter

21 of 41

    Who better to man the blue lines with Shea Weber than Ryan Suter? Suter and Weber make a fantastic defensive duo with chemistry and hockey sense. Alfredsson knows the chemistry will be great for keeping the pressure on Chara.

Team Chara Round 11: Brian Campbell

22 of 41

    Chara is sticking with the trend to grab defensemen, and who better to grab than Brian Campbell? Campbell is a leader on the Panthers who are charting waters unknown to them: First place. Campbell leads the Panthers' defensemen in points, and his scoring abilities will help Chara on the blue line. 

Team Alfredsson Round 12: Alexander Edler

23 of 41

    Alfredsson wants to keep adding defense to match up well against Chara and makes a smart pick with Edler. Edler is on pace for a career year and is nearly at his career-high for goals halfway through the season. Edler's got a great partner in Karlsson too. 

Team Chara Round 12: Kris Letang

24 of 41

    Chara needs to keep grabbing defensemen and does so with Letang. Chara needs another offensive-minded defender, and Letang can work the puck up the ice, which is the perfect counterpart for Campbell. Chara's in the offensive state of mind for this game. 

Team Alfredsson Round 13: Jamie Benn

25 of 41

    A huge surprise this year for the Dallas Stars is Jamie Benn. Leading the team in assists and just two points from leading the team in that category too, Benn will be a perfect anchor for the third line of Alfredsson's team. 

Team Chara Round 13: Dennis Wideman

26 of 41

    With Ovechkin out of the All-Star lineup, Wideman is the perfect player to represent the Capitals. Wideman leads the Capitals' defensive core in goals, assists and points. Chara knows this is an offensive game and wants to win it badly.

Team Alfredsson Round 14: Keith Yandle

27 of 41

    Alfredsson needs two more defensemen in the final two rounds for defensemen, and he starts things off with Yandle. Yandle leads the Coyote defensemen in points, going to show that offense ultimately rules the day in the All-Star game. Alfredsson should be happy with the pick.  

Team Chara Round 14: Dion Phaneuf

28 of 41

    Phaneuf is more known for his punishing defensive play, but make no mistake: The captain can score. Phaneuf has 28 points so far this season and is putting up his best numbers in a Maple Leaf uniform. Chara gets another steal of a pick. 

Team Alfredsson Round 15: Kimmo Timonen

29 of 41

    Timonen is one of the veterans that is putting up big numbers for Philly. Timonen is showing his age in hockey sense and deserves to be in what could be his last All-Star game. 

Team Chara Round 15: Dan Girardi

30 of 41

    Girardi is a leader on a Ranger team that is filled with superstars. He is in the prime of his career and is starting to become one of the elite defensemen in the Eastern Conference. Chara will make sure Mr. Irrelevant of the defensemen will be a big part of his game.  

Team Alfredsson Round 16: James Neal

31 of 41

    James Neal took the NHL by storm in the first few weeks on the season by putting up huge numbers in the absence of Crosby. He and Malkin have kept the Pens in a playoff spot all season. He and Malkin are sure to make some noise in the All-Star game too. 

Team Chara Round 16: Jordan Eberle

32 of 41

    Eberle better start getting used to the All-Star games because he will be on the stage a lot over his career. Eberle is leading the young Oiler offense and is trying to get his team into the playoffs. Chara is going to enjoy having this kid on his team. 

Team Alfredsson Round 17: John Tavares

33 of 41

    A player that is overlooked because he is on the lowly Islanders, John Tavares is making some noise. Alfredsson recognizes the steal that he is and is glad to grab him in the 17th round. After his season, he's going to be a top-10 rounder next year.  

Team Chara Round 17: Tyler Seguin

34 of 41

    Just as with Tim Thomas, Chara is going to make sure that Seguin is on his team. Seguin has played extremely well for a 19-year-old, even one with Stanley Cup Final experience like he has. Seguin, like Eberle, is going to be here often.

Team Alfredsson Round 18: Logan Couture

35 of 41

    On a team full of All-Stars, Logan Couture is often overlooked. But, he deserves to be in the game. Chara has a gem on his hands and will be glad with his pick. 

Team Chara Round 18: Scott Hartnell

36 of 41

    Scott Hartnell has a gritty style of play: He isn't afraid to get into the dirty areas to put the puck in the net. While there probably won't be any grit in the All-Star game, Hartnell is still going to produce. 

Team Alfredsson Round 19: Milan Michalek

37 of 41

    Alfredsson chooses his last pick very wisely as he grabs the final Senator in the draft. Michalek will have a great first All-Star game and will feel very at home on the ice. Good final pick for Alfredsson.

Team Chara Round 19: Jason Pominville

38 of 41

    Jason Pominville is your Mr. Irrelevant 2012. The captain for the Sabres is by no means a bad player, as he has 47 points through this point in the season. Maybe like Kessel did this year, he will have a fantastic season next year. 

Team Alfredsson

39 of 41


    Daniel Alfredsson

    Jason Spezza

    Evgini Malkin

    Steven Stamkos

    Daniel Sedin

    Marion Hossa

    Marian Gaborik

    Jamie Benn

    James Neal

    John Tavares

    Logan Couture

    Milan Michalek



    Shea Weber

    Erik Karlsson

    Ryan Suter

    Alexander Edler

    Keith Yandle

    Kimmo Timonen



    Henrik Lundqvist

    Jimmy Howard

    Jonathan Quick

Team Chara

40 of 41


    Joffrey Lupul

    Claude Giroux

    Pavel Datsyuk

    Henrik Sedin

    Phil Kessel

    Corey Perry

    Patrick Kane

    Jarome Iginla

    Jordan Eberle

    Tyler Seguin

    Scott Hartnell

    Jason Pominville



    Zdeno Chara

    Brian Campbell

    Kris Letang

    Dennis Wideman

    Dion Phaneuf

    Dan Girardi



    Tim Thomas

    Brian Elliot

    Carey Price


41 of 41

    Team Chara.

    Chara made sure to grab the big guns. He chose offense because that is what the All-Star game is about. Team Alfredsson is going to feel like the home team though, because every Senator in the draft is on his team.

    It is going to be a nail-biter.