Super Bowl 2012: What Eli Manning Gains from a Second Ring

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Super Bowl 2012: What Eli Manning Gains from a Second Ring
Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images

Eli Manning isn't the best quarterback in New York Giants history. He isn't even the best quarterback with his own last name.

But both these notions are temporary, and with a second Super Bowl ring he'll be damn close to changing them.

A second ring won't elevate Eli above Phil Simms' passing marks in the Giants record books—he still has plenty of time to do that—but it will tie him with Simms' two Super Bowl rings.

It is true that No. 11 wasn't on the field for the Giants' memorable Super Bowl XXV win, but he did start 14 regular season games and turn in one of his finest statistical seasons before going down with injury that year. Jeff Hostetler led the Giants to the Bowl, but Simms played a major role in that season.

Mike Powell/Getty Images

Eli is well on pace to knock the Giants legend off the top spot in New York's record books, but Super Bowl rings are the most important statistic.

If No. 10 were to equal (virtually pass No. 11's two rings because of the injury) he will eventually be known as the best quarterback in Giants history. It is inevitable that Eli will pass Simms in the books; adding a second ring puts him ahead regardless. 

As for brother Peyton, well, it would become an interesting debate.

Quarterbacks are judged, first and foremost, by winning. All the statistics in the world are great, but they pale in comparison to Super Bowl rings. Peyton's career is not over yet (we believe) and he is easily one of the best to ever line up under center. The things he's done with the Indianapolis Colts—evidenced even further by his absence this season—are nothing short of remarkable.

Andy Lyons/Getty Images

But he does have a 9-10 career postseason mark with one Super Bowl win and one Super Bowl loss.

Another ring won't put Eli ahead of Peyton, but it will close that once insurmountable gap between the two of them.

And remember, Peyton has a full six more seasons in the league than Eli to begin with.

Will Eli Ultimately Be a Hall of Fame-Worthy QB?

Submit Vote vote to see results

Should Eli continue to play at the level he has this season, he will have made a huge jump up the ranks of the current quarterbacks forever. If he adds another Super Bowl ring he'll join a list that includes: Joe Montana, John Elway, Terry Bradshaw, Troy Aikman, Tom Brady, Bob Griese, Roger Staubach, Jim Plunkett, Bart Starr and Ben Roethlisberger.

Eli Manning still has to get back to his second Super Bowl, but if he completes yet another run this year it will truly move him into elite company in his organization, in his family and in history.

Chuckin' the rock on Twitter too.

Follow New York Giants from B/R on Facebook

Follow New York Giants from B/R on Facebook and get the latest updates straight to your newsfeed!

New York Giants

Subscribe Now

By signing up for our newsletter, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Thanks for signing up.